Pizza in Pine Island

“Wow. That's all I can say. We drove out of our way because my daughter wanted a margarita pie. I saw a photo on Google and it looked pretty good. We will only be getting our pizza from this spot from now on. Worth the drive. Amazing crust and the sauce was the best I've had in a while.”

“I stop in at least once a week. Absolutely love their baked clams and Sicilian slices. Staff is friendly, remembers your name and your order. One of my favorite places to eat. Highly recommended.”

“Excellent pizza and lovely people.”

“Alway's a wonderful job! The pizza is amazing! I have 2 picky eaters in my house. They love Franico's. I'm sad the Florida store is closed, it was closer to us. But Pine Island is still around and P.A restaurant. Wonderful pizza and family owned! Alway's a great experience. Highly recommend!”

“This is the best pizza I have had in a while. I was recommended this place from a family member. Food, service, and atmosphere is a solid 10/10! I highly recommend this place to everyone!”

“From a person that was born and raised in the city with eating delicious pizza and moving up here in sussex county.... I can finally that I have found the pizzeria that taste like home! I even ate the crust, the pepperoni pizza was delicious and the sauce was just perfect. With the staff being friendly and sitting in the cute rustic setting, I was enjoying every bit of it.”

“I pre-ordered 10 different pizza pies for an event we were having next door. Their communication was great and it was delivered on time and everyone at the party enjoyed the pizza.”

“Without a doubt there is no better pizza . Highly recommended, hope you get to try it out!”

“good service, kind people and a delicious pizza😋😋”

“Honestly the only pizza I look forward to. Nobody even comes close. Better than NYC pizza.”

“This place is the real deal! ITALIAN all the way. The pizza is delicious, never greasy. They use fresh basil from a local grower. I’ve tried many dishes, all top notch Italian cuisine! They also have the most delicious burgers on bread they bake fresh in-house! Definitely a 10!”

“Clean, friendly, and great pizza!!! Outstanding all the way!!!”

“Not only was the pizza the best, the hospitality that went along with it was incredible. Nico did his best to accommodate our large bus group. We will be back. He made me feel like i was a member of his family….muta grazie Nico!!!! Juelly his attendant was just as hospitable.”